DVD Tip: The Good German

the-good-german.jpgThe Good German (2006), which starred George Clooney and Cate Blanchett, didn’t get many good reviews.  Critics seemed to use the movie’s release as a chance to complain about director Stephen Soderbergh’s career.  The film’s homages to The Third Man, Casablanca, and Italian neorealism (and probably more references a more serious film buff would get) seem to have annoyed reviewers.  There was probably an element of jealousy, too.  When not making arty period films in black and white, Soderbergh and Clooney collaborate on the glitzy Oceans 11-12-13 franchise.  Soderburgh gets respect and big bucks. Clooney lives in an Italian villa and dates gorgeous women. 

Leave all that aside.  I saw The Good German on DVD over the weekend and I loved it.  Yes, the steals from old black and white films are, at times, pretty blatant.  But I love those films, and the use Soderbergh makes of his allusions to them heightens his story. 

Soderbergh, under a pseudonym, also edited the film, which means he is responsible for an astonishing scene near the end of the film involving a marching band, a crowd, a paid assassin and the movies’ two main characters.  

The final scene is very close to the airport scene in Casablanca, but also inverts it.  In Casablanca, Bogart’s Rick discovers his soul at the moment that Ingrid Bergman’s Ilsa leaves his side.  In The Good German, the two main characters also split up at the airport, but for the opposite reason.  (Watch it and you’ll see what I mean.)

Curiously enough, some reviews knocked the cinematography because it wasn’t precisely like the black and white 40’s flicks, with Soderbergh’s film using higher contrast than his models did.  Well, yes, that’s right.  It’s different.  It’s also very effective, focusing our attention on the characters’ eyes, mouths and posture, the conveyors of emotion.  It also allows a better blending with the archival footage by which Soderbergh represents postwar Berlin. 

At the same time, the sharp contrasts are ironic.  We’re in a world of gray in The Good German. It is a microcosm of the moral ambiguity of the Cold War, capturing the U.S./Soviet drama at a point very near its beginning, in a tug-of-war over a German rocketeer who is also a war criminal.  To keep him away from the Russians, some American officials want to keep his evil deeds a secret.  Rockets “that can go halfway around the world” armed with atomic bombs are “the future,” explains a buffoonish Congressman.  And so they were.

Clooney represents the moral certainty that Americans brought into WWII.  His disillusionment at the end covers not just the postwar activities of the US government, but the whole notion of human goodness.  And that disillusionment is written on Clooney’s high-contrast face, in a devastating long take that closes the movie.  The Good German, a cinematic treat on many levels, also bucks “the greatest generation” myth, showing how WWII injected moral relativism into the bloodstream of our national security apparatus, and eventually our body politic.  To a degree scarcely acknowledged in pop culture, that war brutalized the Americans who fought it. It changed us. Maybe we were the last innocents, but after the war, there were no innocents.  Just the decieved.

I foresee this film’s reputation rising in the near future.  Get in now at the ground floor.

3 thoughts on “DVD Tip: The Good German

  1. Funny, my wife and I watched the same film over the weekend and hated it. The homages were so heavy-handed, and the acting so bad (Cate Blanchett’s only bad film in her whole career), that it was impossible to tell whether Soderbergh had intended a satire, a message film, or one of those “look at all my cool, in-references” post-mod Tarantino films.

    I guess you fell for the “cool, in-references” movie.

    We loved that the George Clooney character got beat up every time he turned around. It was almost like watching Chevy Chase do Gerald Ford.

    Now, the surprisingly good movie we also saw was STRANGER THAN FICTION, with Will Ferrell. And ONCE, an independent Irish film made for 100,000 Euros, is a masterpiece of indie filmmaking. We returned the rental disc and BOUGHT a copy to study over and over again, it’s that good. Soderbergh should watch it, and go back to making indie films.

  2. Strange coincidence. We also saw “Once” this weekend, and we loved it too. Interesting style. A lot of long takes, as if the movie slipped into being a documentary at certain points. And yeah, “Stranger than Fiction” is pretty brilliant. I should look at that again.

    But I’ll defend my endorsement of “The Good German.” I didn’t take it as a “cool” movie so much as a conservative, throwback movie in terms of style, characterization and look. I just rewatched-twice-“The Third Man.” Is it so wrong to wish for another movie that adopted a similar aesthetic? A similar aesthetic, turned on its head. At heart, the heroes of “The Third Man” and “Casablanca” are anyone identified with the non-Soviet allies. In this movie, Clooney’s character can only count on himself. The Americans are just as expedient as the Soviets, and both are (in pursuit of what they deem worthy causes) only marginally less expedient than the Nazis.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s